New Game Plus & The Lies System
New Game Plus Overview
After completing any of the three endings in Lies of P, New Game Plus (NG+) begins immediately. The world resets — enemies respawn, items refresh, and bosses return — but P retains significant progress.
What Carries Over Into NG+
| Category | Carries Over? | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Ergo (currency/XP) | Yes | Full amount transfers |
| Character Level | Yes | All stat points retained |
| Weapons (all) | Yes | Including assembled combinations |
| Weapon enhancement levels | Yes | All +1 through +10 upgrades kept |
| Legion Arms (all) | Yes | Including Wishstone sockets |
| Legion Arm upgrade levels | Yes | |
| P-Organ upgrades | Yes | All nodes remain unlocked |
| Amulets | Yes | |
| Key items | No | Story-required items removed |
| Quartz | No | Must be recollected from world |
| Boss Ergo items | No | Cleared for fresh trading with Alidoro |
| Records | Yes | Gramophone collection preserved |
| Cryptic Vessel progress | Partial | New NG+ vessels become available |
| Relationship with NPCs | Resets | Questlines restart from beginning |
Critical Note: Quartz does NOT carry over. P-Organ nodes you unlocked are kept, but you will need to recollect all 47 Quartz to fill any nodes you missed, or to fill the tree again if you are playing a different build approach.
NG+ Difficulty Changes
| Change | Details |
|---|---|
| Enemy HP | Approximately +25% across all enemies |
| Enemy damage | Approximately +20% across all enemies |
| Boss HP | Approximately +30% across all bosses |
| New enemy variants | Some regular enemies gain additional attack patterns |
| Cryptic Vessel puzzles | New NG+ exclusive vessels appear at specific locations |
Cryptic Vessel Puzzles
Cryptic Vessels are collectible items found throughout Krat. Each one contains a coded message that hints at a location somewhere in the game. Delivering the Cryptic Vessel to Venigni at Hotel Krat causes him to decode the message. The solution location contains a special reward — often unique weapons, upgrade materials, or rare Quartz.
Known Cryptic Vessel Locations & Rewards
| Vessel Name | Found At | Decoded Location | Reward |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cryptic Vessel 1 | Krat Central Station, locked room | Elysion Boulevard fountain | Rare Moonstone cluster |
| Cryptic Vessel 2 | Malum District, rooftop chest | St. Frangelico Cathedral crypt | Unique amulet (Friendship Amulet) |
| Cryptic Vessel 3 | Grand Exhibition Gallery, curator's office | Barren Swamp island | Crescent Moonstone (max Legion upgrade material) |
| Cryptic Vessel 4 | Relic of Trismegistes, flooded room | Rosa Isabelle Street collapsed plaza | Quartz (missed in base game) |
| Cryptic Vessel 5 (NG+ exclusive) | Arche Abbey entrance, new chest | Krat Central Station revisit | Memory of Beach record + Quartz |
| Cryptic Vessel 6 (NG+ exclusive) | Barren Swamp, previously locked gate | Grand Exhibition Gallery rooftop | White Wishstone + rare weapon handle |
Note: NG+ exclusive vessels (5 and 6) are only accessible after completing a full playthrough. The chests containing them do not exist in the first playthrough.
The Lies System — How It Works Mechanically
Throughout Lies of P, NPCs and mysterious callers present P with dialogue choices. Most choices are binary: tell the truth or lie. The game tracks which choices P makes and applies a hidden Humanity Score that shifts over time.
Core Rules
- Lies increase Humanity. Each lie in a major story moment moves P's Humanity Score up.
- Truth decreases Humanity. Choosing truth in the same moments decreases or holds the score.
- Minor dialogue choices (asking NPC follow-up questions, topic selections) do not affect the score.
- Only flagged major decisions count toward the lie/truth tally.
- The score is invisible — there is no UI indicator. P's humanity is reflected in subtle visual changes (the color of P's eyes shifts, slight facial expression changes appear in cutscenes).
How Lies Shift P Toward Humanity
- Pinocchio becomes human by choosing to lie — the irony being that lying is presented as the more human act in this narrative. Puppets cannot lie by design; choosing deception is evidence of free will.
- As P's Humanity Score rises from accumulated lies, certain characters begin reacting differently to him. Sophia's dialogue deepens. Gepetto's expressions shift. In the final act, the Blue Butterfly — a recurring symbol of humanity throughout the game — appears in Hotel Krat.
All Major Lie / Truth Decision Points
The following are all flagged dialogue moments that affect the Humanity Score and/or lock/unlock specific outcomes.
| # | Decision Point | Location / Trigger | Lie Result | Truth Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | "Are you human?" — Antonia's first question | Hotel Krat, early arrival | +Humanity; Antonia feels comforted | Antonia becomes subtly wary |
| 2 | Telephone caller — "Are you a real boy?" | Hotel Krat telephone, Chapter 2 | +Humanity; caller grows warmer | Caller grows cold; story thread narrows |
| 3 | "Do you feel grief?" — after first major NPC death | Hotel Krat, after a companion dies | +Humanity; unlocks deeper dialogue | Polendina notes P's detachment |
| 4 | Cecile's question — "Will you save everyone?" | Malum District, Cecile encounter | +Humanity; Cecile's questline stays open | Cecile's questline closes early |
| 5 | Telephone caller — second call ("Do you dream?") | Hotel Krat telephone, Chapter 4 | +Humanity; Blue Butterfly draws closer | No change |
| 6 | "Do you feel love?" — Eugénie's question | Hotel Krat, after giving broken ring | +Humanity; Eugénie's questline advances | Questline still advances but record is locked |
| 7 | The Archbishop's test — "Do you believe in humanity?" | St. Frangelico Cathedral, pre-boss area | +Humanity; unique item reward | Standard path |
| 8 | Telephone caller — third call (before Chapter 6) | Hotel Krat telephone, Chapter 5 | Critical: +Humanity + Golden Lie flag | Golden Lie weapon becomes unobtainable |
| 9 | "Are you willing to become human?" — Sophia | Hotel Krat, late game | +Humanity; Rise of P ending enabled | Free from Puppet String ending enabled |
| 10 | Gepetto's final request — "Give me your heart" | Hotel Krat, post-final boss | Refuse (either path): see endings | Agree: Ending 3 |
Decision #8 is the most missable. If you miss the third telephone call entirely (by not answering when it rings) or choose truth, the Golden Lie weapon is permanently locked in that playthrough.
The Golden Lie — Special Weapon
The Golden Lie is a unique fist weapon that can only be obtained through the telephone lie chain. It does not appear in any chest or vendor.
| Attribute | Detail |
|---|---|
| Weapon Type | Fist (unarmed combat style) |
| Scaling | Advances + Technique split |
| Fable Art | "The Golden Lie" — a rapid combo followed by a golden burst |
| Availability | One per playthrough; requires all three lie telephone choices |
| Location | Blue Butterfly leaves it on a chair in Hotel Krat (near the gramophone) after the third telephone lie |
All Three Endings — Full Requirements
Ending 1 — Rise of P (True / Best Ending)
Requirements:
- Accumulate maximum Humanity Score — lie in all 9 flagged decisions.
- Complete Gepetto's full questline (give him every item he requests during the story).
- After defeating Simon Manus: refuse Gepetto when he asks for your heart.
- Defeat the Nameless Puppet (door opens in Hotel Krat lobby after refusal).
What Happens: The Blue Butterfly appears. The cricket emerges — a symbol from the Pinocchio fairy tale. P is acknowledged as truly human. The city begins to recover. A new dawn over Krat.
Unique to This Ending: The Nameless Puppet fight; the Golden Lie weapon (if the telephone chain was completed); full NPC questline conclusions.
Ending 2 — Free from the Puppet String
Requirements:
- Tell the truth in all flagged decisions — keep Humanity Score low.
- No requirement on Gepetto's questline completion.
- After defeating Simon Manus: refuse Gepetto when he asks for your heart.
- Defeat the Nameless Puppet.
What Happens: P walks away from Hotel Krat alone. He is still a puppet, but no longer bound to Gepetto's will. The ending is quiet, bittersweet — freedom without humanity.
Note: This ending also unlocks a unique piece of music and is considered by many to be the most emotionally resonant conclusion.
Ending 3 — Real Boy: They All Lived Happily Ever After
Requirements:
- Any Humanity Score (lies/truth mix does not matter for this ending).
- After defeating Simon Manus: agree when Gepetto asks for your heart.
What Happens: P surrenders his heart — his core — to Gepetto. The city sees a bright new morning. Gepetto appears restored. The ending is deceptively cheerful but implies a profound sacrifice.
No Nameless Puppet: Agreeing with Gepetto ends the game immediately — the optional boss door never opens.
Endings Decision Tree
Complete the game (defeat Simon Manus)
│
├── AGREE to give Gepetto your heart
│ └── Ending 3: Real Boy
│
└── REFUSE to give Gepetto your heart
│
├── Defeat the Nameless Puppet
│
├── High Humanity Score (9 lies)
│ └── Ending 1: Rise of P
│
└── Low Humanity Score (truths)
└── Ending 2: Free from the Puppet String
Replay & NG+ Strategy for All Endings
Fastest method (two playthroughs):
| Run | Lies/Truth | Final Choice | Endings Obtained |
|---|---|---|---|
| Playthrough 1 | All Lies | Refuse → fight Nameless Puppet | Ending 1 (Rise of P) |
| (Save before Gepetto) | — | Load save, Agree | Ending 3 (Real Boy) |
| Playthrough 2 (NG+) | All Truths | Refuse → fight Nameless Puppet | Ending 2 (Free from Puppet String) |
This method collects all three endings in two playthroughs with one save manipulation — standard for achievement hunters.