NPC Questline: Patches the Hyena

Length: Short (two key encounters; primarily functions as a merchant afterward) Rewards: Access to Patches' merchant stock (Humanity, Twin Humanities, rare items), Humanity on first meeting, comedic closure of a recurring series joke Missable: Yes — killing Patches ends his questline and permanently removes his merchant stock; if you are a cleric, his first encounter includes a unique interaction; sparing him is always the correct choice


Overview

Patches the Hyena is a recurring character across the entire Souls series and Elden Ring — appearing in Dark Souls, Dark Souls II (as Unbreakable Patches in spirit, though the DS2 appearance differs), Dark Souls III, and Elden Ring. He is always some version of the same person: a cheerful, amoral opportunist who pretends to be your friend while actively looking for ways to rob you or throw you into a pit.

In Dark Souls Remastered, his questline is brief but memorable. He kicks you into a pit in the Catacombs. He feels bad about it afterward (specifically because you are not a cleric — if you are a cleric, he feels somewhat less bad). He moves to Firelink Shrine and becomes a merchant, selling rare items including Humanity and Twin Humanities that are otherwise difficult to farm.

Killing Patches ends your access to those items permanently. Sparing him means you have a recurring merchant for rare consumables. The calculus is straightforward: be merciful, get merchant access.

The more interesting angle is what Patches represents across the series — the person who survives everything by being consistently, cheerfully selfish in a world full of idealists and warriors who die for their beliefs.


Step-by-Step Walkthrough

Step 1 — The Catacombs Encounter

Location: Catacombs — a chest room in the middle section of the Catacombs, reached after the second or third bonfire area.

The Catacombs are Dark Souls' bone-filled undead burial ground, reached from Firelink Shrine via the lower path. They are dark, full of skeleton enemies that regenerate unless killed with Divine weapons, and home to several traps. Patches fits here perfectly.

Deep in the Catacombs, you will come to a room with a chest at the far end. Patches is standing nearby, very helpful-looking. He mentions the chest and encourages you to go take a look at it.

If you approach the chest: Patches kicks you into the pit below. The pit has skeleton enemies at the bottom. You take fall damage, land among the skeletons, and have to fight your way back out via a ladder.

When you climb back out of the pit and find Patches again, he apologizes. Sort of. His apology is calibrated — he expresses remorse in proportion to how much guilt he is comfortable with, which is not very much. He gives you a Humanity item as a peace offering.

If you are a cleric: He has a special reaction. Patches has a strong dislike of clerics — he finds their faith-based certainty morally irritating, or perhaps simply profitable. If you are playing as a Cleric class, he kicks you into the pit with somewhat less conflict about it, and his subsequent apology is adjusted accordingly. He still apologizes. Mostly.

Exhaust all dialogue after climbing out of the pit. Do not attack him.

Reward: 1 Humanity (apology offering from Patches)

He relocates to Firelink Shrine.


Step 2 — Patches at Firelink Shrine

Location: Firelink Shrine — near the main bonfire or in the adjacent corridor, after the Catacombs encounter.

After being encountered in the Catacombs, Patches sets up shop at Firelink Shrine. He is cheerful, informal, and makes no further reference to the pit incident unless prompted. He is in the business of selling things now.

Exhaust all dialogue. He is pleasant in the way that someone who does not consider themselves a bad person is pleasant — he has compartmentalized the pit entirely and is focused on the present commercial opportunity.

He sells items here for the remainder of the game.


Patches' Merchant Stock

Patches sells several items that are otherwise rare or difficult to farm:

Item Use
Humanity Soft Humanity counter increase; used to kindle bonfires, reverse hollowing, Chaos covenant contribution
Twin Humanities Grants 2 soft Humanity at once; more efficient per slot
Lloyd's Talisman Blocks Estus Flask use for enemies it hits (useful in co-op/PvP)
Ring of Sacrifice On death, lose nothing but the ring shatters (useful for risky areas)
Cracked Eye Orb Allows minor invasion into other players' worlds (covenant-related)
Prism Stone Drops to test fall heights — glows brighter when the fall will kill you
Indictment Report a hostile player for sin accumulation

The most valuable items in his stock are Humanity and Twin Humanities. Humanity is needed for:

  • Staying in human form (required for summoning)
  • Kindling bonfires to increase Estus Flask charges (each kindle costs 1 Humanity, up to 20 charges with Rite of Kindling)
  • Increasing soft Humanity stat (improves Item Discovery and Chaos scaling)
  • Chaos Servant covenant ranking (requires large Humanity donations)

Patches provides the most reliable non-farming source of Humanity in the game. This is why killing him is a mistake.


The One Exception: When to Kill Patches

There is no circumstances where killing Patches is the optimal choice for gameplay. His merchant stock is too valuable, and the Humanity economy in Dark Souls is important enough that a reliable vendor for it outweighs any item he would drop.

If you do kill him: he drops a Humanity item and whatever equipment he has on him. This is not worth more than his continued vendor services.

The only reason to kill Patches is the same reason you'd throw him into a pit: because you can.


Patches Across the Souls Series

Patches appears in every mainline Souls game and Elden Ring in some form. His character is always recognizably the same, adjusted for the setting:

Dark Souls (this game): Kicks you into a pit in the Catacombs. Moves to Firelink. Sells Humanity.

Dark Souls II: A character with the same archetype and similar behavior appears, though the continuity of "Patches" as a named character is handled differently. He appears in the Grave of Saints and in the DLC content.

Dark Souls III: Patches returns explicitly named in Firelink Shrine's rafters. He tricks you into falling into a trap (lowered by a lever he controls), apologizes, moves downstairs, and becomes a merchant. Same as always. He sells several rare items and has extended questline dialogue tied to Greirat of the Undead Settlement.

Elden Ring: Patches appears in the Murkwater Cave in Limgrave. He is perhaps the most fully realized version of the character — his encounter there is a miniature questline involving him hiding in a chest (as a mimic trap), then becoming a traveling merchant who admits that he thinks you are probably better than the Elden Lords he's watched come through. He has, in a sense, been doing this long enough to have opinions.

The consistent element across all appearances: he survives by being useful after being terrible, and the player is always incentivized to let him. His longevity as a character is its own comment on pragmatism versus idealism in a world full of people who die for their beliefs.


Rewards Summary

Reward How to Obtain
1 Humanity Climb out of the Catacombs pit; Patches' apology
Patches' merchant stock Spare Patches; he moves to Firelink Shrine
Humanity (purchasable) Buy from Patches throughout the game
Twin Humanities (purchasable) Buy from Patches throughout the game

Lore Notes

Patches calls himself a Hyena because hyenas are scavengers — he takes what others have earned or abandoned and sells it for profit. He is not a fighter, not a hero, not a seeker. He is someone who noticed that the world contains many valuable items and many dead people who no longer need them.

His dislike of clerics specifically is one of the series' running jokes — he finds faith annoying, possibly because faith-based people are less susceptible to the kind of transactional reasoning he operates on. A cleric who trusts in the gods is not easily persuaded that getting kicked into a pit was actually your fault for being too curious.

In Elden Ring, Patches refers to a past version of himself following a "Saint" who led him into ruin — suggesting that at some point in his personal history, Patches was himself a believer who got burned. The Hyena identity may be the conclusion he drew from that experience: the world is full of people with big ideas who will get you killed. Better to be the one doing the selling.

He is not wrong. He is also not right. He is, in any case, consistently alive, which is more than most NPCs in Lordran can say.