Boss Soul Transposition Guide — Dark Souls III
After defeating a Lord of Cinder or named boss, you receive their Boss Soul. These souls can be consumed for a large amount of regular souls, but the better use is almost always transposition — converting them into unique weapons, spells, or shields unavailable anywhere else in the game.
How Transposition Works
- Defeat the Crystal Sage in the Road of Sacrifices and obtain the Transposing Kiln.
- Bring the Transposing Kiln to Ludleth of Courland at Firelink Shrine and give it to him.
- Speak to Ludleth again and select "Transpose Soul" — he will show you all available options for each boss soul in your inventory.
- You can only make one item per boss soul (choose carefully).
- Ludleth can be killed for the Kiln if you haven't given it to him yet — do not kill him.
Coiled Sword Fragment (Special)
| Source | Item | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Soul of the Usurper (Iudex Gundyr) | Coiled Sword Fragment | Infinite-use Homeward Bone effect |
The Coiled Sword Fragment is one of the most useful utility items in the game. It functions exactly like a Homeward Bone but has infinite uses — it never runs out. Obtained by transposing the Soul of the Usurper (Iudex Gundyr's soul, found in Untended Graves on NG+, OR by accessing the hidden path to Untended Graves in your first playthrough). The Untended Graves Champion Gundyr drops the Soul of the Usurper; regular Iudex Gundyr drops the Coiled Sword (used to light the bonfire at the start).
All Boss Soul Transpositions
Soul of Iudex Gundyr (Tutorial Boss)
| Option | Type | Recommended? |
|---|---|---|
| Gundyr's Halberd | Weapon | Yes — excellent Strength/Dex halberd with unique Skill |
| Prisoner's Chain | Ring | Best choice for most builds |
Verdict: Prisoner's Chain (+5 Vigor, +5 End, +5 Vit with minor damage penalty) is one of the best rings in the game. Take it unless you specifically want the halberd.
Soul of Vordt of the Boreal Valley
| Option | Type | Recommended? |
|---|---|---|
| Vordt's Great Hammer | Weapon | Niche — Frost effect, Strength build |
| Pontiff's Left Eye | Ring | Best choice for most builds |
Verdict: Pontiff's Left Eye restores HP on successive hits. Take this unless you are running a dedicated Strength/Frost build for the novelty.
Soul of the Rotted Greatwood (Curse-Rotted Greatwood)
| Option | Type | Recommended? |
|---|---|---|
| Hollowslayer Greatsword | Weapon | Best choice for Dex/Quality builds |
| Arstor's Spear | Weapon | Niche — Poison DoT spear |
Verdict: Hollowslayer Greatsword is one of the best greatswords in the game. It deals 20% bonus damage to hollow enemies (which is a huge portion of the total enemy roster in DS3) and has a fast, versatile moveset. Take this.
Soul of Crystal Sage
| Option | Type | Recommended? |
|---|---|---|
| Crystal Sage's Rapier | Weapon | Best choice (item discovery utility) |
| Crystal Hail | Sorcery | Secondary option for sorcerers |
Verdict: Crystal Sage's Rapier held in the off-hand grants +50 Item Discovery, making it one of the most important utility items in the game for farming. Take it. You can farm Crystal Hail from Crystal Lizards or buy it elsewhere.
Soul of the Deacons of the Deep
| Option | Type | Recommended? |
|---|---|---|
| Cleric's Candlestick | Weapon/Catalyst | Niche — Faith/Int hybrid tool |
| Deep Soul | Sorcery | Situational |
Verdict: Neither option is exceptional. Cleric's Candlestick functions as both a straight sword and a sorcery catalyst, which is unique. If you're not running a hybrid build, consume this soul for the souls.
Soul of Abyss Watchers
| Option | Type | Recommended? |
|---|---|---|
| Farron Greatsword | Weapon | Best choice for Dex builds |
| Wolf Knight's Greatsword | Weapon | Alternative Strength option |
Verdict: Farron Greatsword is a paired ultra greatsword with an incredibly unique flowing moveset (inspired by Artorias). It's one of the most fun-to-use weapons in the game. Wolf Knight's Greatsword can also be obtained from the Watchdogs of Farron covenant, so Farron Greatsword is the recommended transpose.
Soul of High Lord Wolnir
| Option | Type | Recommended? |
|---|---|---|
| Wolnir's Holy Sword | Weapon | Decent Faith-scaling greatsword |
| Black Serpent | Pyromancy | Best choice for pyromancers |
Verdict: Black Serpent is one of the best PvP pyromancies — it hugs the ground and curves toward opponents in ways that are very hard to dodge. For Faith builds, Wolnir's Holy Sword is a solid choice. If you're a pyromancer, take Black Serpent.
Soul of the Old Demon King
| Option | Type | Recommended? |
|---|---|---|
| Old King's Great Hammer | Weapon | Best choice for Strength/Pyro builds |
| Chaos Bed Vestiges | Pyromancy | Best if you're a pyromancer |
Verdict: Chaos Bed Vestiges is arguably the strongest offensive pyromancy spell in the game — a highly recommended choice for pure pyromancers. Old King's Great Hammer has a built-in pyromancy flame and deals both physical and fire damage, which is fantastic on Strength/Pyro hybrids. If you're a pyromancer, take Chaos Bed Vestiges. If you're melee with pyromancy dipping, take the hammer.
Soul of Pontiff Sulyvahn
| Option | Type | Recommended? |
|---|---|---|
| Profaned Greatsword | Weapon | Best choice for Strength builds |
| Chaos Blade | Weapon | Dex option with HP cost |
Verdict: Profaned Greatsword is an exceptional ultra greatsword — it has a unique skill that creates a flaming blade buff and deals tremendous poise damage. One of the best Strength weapons in the game. Take this for any Strength build.
Soul of Aldrich
| Option | Type | Recommended? |
|---|---|---|
| Lifehunt Scythe | Weapon | Unique Faith/Bleed reaper |
| Darkmoon Longbow | Weapon | Faith-scaling bow |
Verdict: Lifehunt Scythe has a self-damage mechanic (drains your own HP on successful bleed proc) which makes it impractical for most builds. Darkmoon Longbow is useful for Faith builds that want a scaling ranged option. Neither is meta — consume the soul if you have no plans for either.
Soul of Yhorm the Giant
| Option | Type | Recommended? |
|---|---|---|
| Storm Ruler | Weapon | Boss gimmick weapon (near-useless outside Yhorm's arena) |
| Yhorm's Great Machete | Weapon | Best choice — strong Strength weapon |
| Yhorm's Greatshield | Shield | High stability greatshield |
Verdict: Storm Ruler is only useful to trivialize the Yhorm fight itself — you can find a copy inside his arena for free, so do not transpose for it. Yhorm's Great Machete is one of the heaviest-hitting greataxes in the game. Yhorm's Greatshield is excellent for tank builds. Machete is the most universally useful choice.
Soul of the Dancer
| Option | Type | Recommended? |
|---|---|---|
| Dancer's Enchanted Swords | Weapon | Excellent paired curved swords |
| Soothing Sunlight | Miracle | Best choice for healers |
Verdict: Dancer's Enchanted Swords are aesthetically amazing but require 16 Strength, 14 Dex, and scale on a dual-wield moveset. They're a strong Dex weapon with unique attacks. Soothing Sunlight is one of the most powerful healing miracles in the game, healing far more HP than Heal Aid. For a pure Faith healer, Soothing Sunlight is a must-have. Pick based on your build.
Soul of Dragonslayer Armour
| Option | Type | Recommended? |
|---|---|---|
| Dragonslayer Greataxe | Weapon | Best choice — top-tier Strength weapon |
| Dragonslayer Greatshield | Shield | Best stability greatshield in the game |
Verdict: Dragonslayer Greataxe deals lightning damage and is one of the best-scaling Strength weapons in the game. Dragonslayer Greatshield has the highest stability of any greatshield. Both are excellent. Choose based on whether you're a pure melee attacker or a tank.
Soul of the Twin Princes (Lothric, Younger Prince)
| Option | Type | Recommended? |
|---|---|---|
| Lothric's Holy Sword | Weapon | Excellent Faith/Dex greatsword |
| Lorian's Greatsword | Weapon | High damage Strength/Faith ultra greatsword |
Verdict: Lothric's Holy Sword has incredible range, good scaling, and a powerful weapon art. Lorian's Greatsword hits incredibly hard and has a teleporting skill inspired by the boss fight. Both are excellent late-game weapons. Lothric's Holy Sword edges ahead for versatility on Faith/Dex hybrid builds.
Soul of the Nameless King (Archdragon Peak — Optional)
| Option | Type | Recommended? |
|---|---|---|
| Storm Curved Sword | Weapon | One of the best Dex weapons in the game |
| Dragonslayer Swordspear | Weapon | Lightning-infused spear |
Verdict: Storm Curved Sword is widely regarded as one of the best curved swords in the game for Dex builds — great moveset, exceptional weapon art, and solid damage. Dragonslayer Swordspear scales with both Dex and Faith, with a ranged lightning throw weapon art. Storm Curved Sword is the more universally applicable choice.
Soul of the Lords (Soul of Cinder — Final Boss)
| Option | Type | Recommended? |
|---|---|---|
| Firelink Greatsword | Weapon | Unique sword with all-element attacks |
| Sunlight Spear | Miracle | Best choice for Faith builds |
Verdict: Sunlight Spear is one of the most powerful offensive miracles in the game — a massive homing bolt with high Faith scaling. It is the premiere offensive miracle and every Faith build should have it. Firelink Greatsword is stylistically incredible (cycling through fire, magic, lightning, and dark damage) but the Sunlight Spear win is clear for casters.
Quick Reference Table
| Boss | Option A | Option B | Best Pick |
|---|---|---|---|
| Iudex Gundyr | Gundyr's Halberd | Prisoner's Chain | Prisoner's Chain |
| Vordt | Vordt's Great Hammer | Pontiff's Left Eye | Left Eye (most builds) |
| Rotted Greatwood | Hollowslayer Greatsword | Arstor's Spear | Hollowslayer GS |
| Crystal Sage | Crystal Sage's Rapier | Crystal Hail | Rapier (item discovery) |
| Deacons | Cleric's Candlestick | Deep Soul | Consume (neither is great) |
| Abyss Watchers | Farron Greatsword | Wolf Knight's Greatsword | Farron GS |
| High Lord Wolnir | Wolnir's Holy Sword | Black Serpent | Build-dependent |
| Old Demon King | Old King's Great Hammer | Chaos Bed Vestiges | Build-dependent |
| Pontiff Sulyvahn | Profaned Greatsword | Chaos Blade | Profaned GS |
| Aldrich | Lifehunt Scythe | Darkmoon Longbow | Consume |
| Yhorm | Yhorm's Great Machete | Yhorm's Greatshield | Machete |
| Dancer | Dancer's Enchanted Swords | Soothing Sunlight | Build-dependent |
| Dragonslayer Armour | Dragonslayer Greataxe | Dragonslayer Greatshield | Greataxe (most builds) |
| Twin Princes | Lothric's Holy Sword | Lorian's Greatsword | Lothric's Holy Sword |
| Nameless King | Storm Curved Sword | Dragonslayer Swordspear | Storm CS |
| Soul of Cinder | Firelink Greatsword | Sunlight Spear | Sunlight Spear (Faith) |