NG+ & All Endings Guide — Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin

Dark Souls II's New Game Plus cycle is the deepest in the trilogy. The game's Bonfire Intensity system means NG+ isn't just a difficulty reskin — it's a progression layer with unique items, new enemy placements, and escalating challenge that caps at Intensity 8. This guide covers everything that carries over, the endings, and how to approach each cycle.


Starting New Game Plus

When you defeat the final boss and reach the Throne of Want, you can:

  1. Sit on the throne to immediately start NG+, OR
  2. Walk away from the throne — this keeps you in your current cycle with everything preserved, and you can start NG+ later from any bonfire by selecting "Begin Journey 2."

There is no going back once you begin the next journey. The world resets. Choose carefully.


What Carries Over Into NG+

Carries Over Does NOT Carry Over
All character levels and stats Bonfires unlocked
All weapons, armor, and shields Keys and door states
All rings (including +1/+2 variants collected) NPC locations and quest progress
All spells and catalysts in inventory Enemy placement (some enemies respawn in different spots in Scholar of the First Sin)
All upgrade materials Petrified NPCs — they reset
Estus Flask charges (shard count carries over) Bone Dust burned (Estus potency resets to 0)
Covenant rank progress Boss completions
Boss souls in your inventory Transpositions already made
Fragrant Branches of Yore in inventory Petrified NPCs/items that were unpetrified
Soul Memory (accumulates across all cycles) Area exploration markers
Gesture collection Respawnable enemy kill counts

Critical note on Fragrant Branches of Yore: If you carry Branches into NG+, Straid and Ornifex will be petrified again and require new Branches to unpetrify. Any Branches you have in inventory carry over, but Branches you already consumed are gone. Many players farm or buy extras before transitioning.

Critical note on Estus: Your flask charge count carries over (you keep all the Estus Shards you collected), but the potency boost from Sublime Bone Dust is reset to +0. You need to burn Bone Dust again in NG+ to restore Estus heal potency.


Bonfire Intensity System

The Bonfire Intensity system is DS2's NG+ escalation mechanic — and it is more granular than any other Souls game.

Intensity How Achieved
1 Base playthrough (NG)
2 NG+ OR burning one Bonfire Ascetic
3 NG+2 OR two Bonfire Ascetics
4 NG+3 OR three Ascetics
5–7 NG+4 through NG+6 or Ascetic stacking
8 Maximum — NG+7 or seven Ascetics

At higher intensities:

  • Enemy HP increases significantly per tier (roughly 10–20% per level)
  • Enemy damage increases per tier
  • Soul rewards increase — roughly doubling from NG to NG+7
  • Some unique items only exist at Intensity 2 or higher — they are not accessible in base NG without burning an Ascetic

Intensity-Exclusive Items

Item Minimum Intensity Location
Simpleton's Ring Intensity 2 Memory of Orro (Forest area)
Second Life Ring +3 Intensity 3+ Drangleic Castle loot
Bonfire Ascetic (extra copies) Intensity 2+ Various chests
Certain enemy-only drops Intensity 2+ Enemy variant changes in Scholar of the First Sin

Enemy Count Cap and Company of Champions

In the base game, most enemies stop respawning after being killed 12 times. They become permanently dead for that cycle. In NG+, the counter resets — all enemies respawn again.

The Company of Champions covenant removes the respawn cap permanently (enemies never stop spawning), which is one reason it dramatically increases game difficulty.


Scholar of the First Sin — NG+ Enemy Changes

In Scholar of the First Sin specifically, enemy placement changes between NG and NG+ cycles more dramatically than in the original DS2. Some enemies are moved to different positions, new enemy variants appear (including red phantom NPCs that invade at set locations), and some ambushes are rearranged. Veteran players who memorize NG positions should expect surprises in NG+ Scholar playthroughs.


All 3 Endings

Ending 1: Link the Curse (Default — Sit on the Throne)

Prerequisites: None. Simply defeat Nashandra and approach the Throne of Want.

How to trigger: Sit on the Throne of Want.

What happens: The Bearer of the Curse sits upon the throne and becomes the new monarch of Drangleic, linking the curse as previous monarchs did. The cycle of undead suffering continues — the Age of Fire is maintained through another sacrifice.

Narrative significance: The default ending. You succeed in fulfilling the purpose that drew you to Drangleic, but the cycle is perpetuated rather than broken. Nashandra wanted to claim the throne for herself and use its power — by defeating her and taking the throne yourself, you prevent her dominion but continue the very curse you sought to cure.

Achievement/Trophy: "Throne of Want"


Ending 2: Leave the Throne (Refuse — Walk Away)

Prerequisites: None. Simply do not sit on the Throne.

How to trigger: After defeating Nashandra, walk away from the Throne of Want without interacting with it. The Emerald Herald appears and asks if you truly wish to refuse. Confirm.

What happens: The Bearer of the Curse refuses the throne entirely. Rather than perpetuating the cycle, you reject the role of monarch. The Emerald Herald sends you onward to whatever comes next, unbound by the curse's demands.

Narrative significance: A quiet rejection of the entire premise. Dark Souls II is, thematically, about questioning whether linking the flame (or perpetuating cycles of power) is ever worth the cost. Walking away says no — but it leaves no resolution, just freedom.

Achievement/Trophy: "Throne Watcher and Defender" (from defeating those bosses) — walking away does not grant a separate achievement in the base game.


Ending 3: The Third Ending — Aldia's Confrontation (Scholar of the First Sin Exclusive)

Prerequisites — speak to Aldia three times during the playthrough:

Aldia, Scholar of the First Sin, is the title character of the definitive edition. He appears at three specific locations during a playthrough. You must speak to him at each location before the final boss.

Appearance Location Condition
First Aldia's Keep — in his study/laboratory Reach Aldia's Keep and explore it thoroughly. He appears as a shadowy presence near the bonfire at the end of the area.
Second At the bonfire after the Dragon Aerie After crossing the Dragon Aerie bridge, he appears at the bonfire before Dragon Shrine.
Third At the Throne of Want — before or after Nashandra He manifests as a final optional confrontation at the throne area after defeating Nashandra, IF you have spoken to him twice before.

Important: You must exhaust his dialogue at each encounter. He will not progress to the next appearance unless you fully speak to him at the previous one.

How to trigger the ending: After defeating Nashandra, instead of sitting on the throne or walking away, wait for Aldia to appear and speak with him. A final confrontation occurs.

What happens: Aldia presents a third option — a philosophical challenge. He reveals that the cure to the undead curse is impossible; the only choices are to perpetuate the cycle, die permanently, or walk the path between. He offers no solution, only clarity. The Bearer of the Curse walks forward into uncertainty, free of the throne's demand but also free of the cycle's promise.

Narrative significance: The true ending of Scholar of the First Sin. Aldia is the game's thematic heart — a scholar who attempted to understand and break the curse through experimentation (hence the grotesque creatures in his Keep). He failed and became something monstrous, but he reached a kind of enlightenment: the cycle cannot be truly broken, but it can be refused with open eyes. This ending acknowledges the futility without despair.

Achievement/Trophy: "Vendor of Souls" (meeting Aldia for the first time) + "Heir of Light" (defeating Aldia in the confrontation, if applicable in your version).


NG+ Goals by Cycle

NG (First Playthrough)

  • Learn the game; invest in ADP early
  • Complete boss transpositions for your build (Straid and Ornifex)
  • Collect all Fragrant Branches of Yore — save at least 2 extras for NG+
  • Find and speak with Aldia three times (Aldia's Keep, Dragon Aerie, Throne of Want) for the third ending
  • Collect all 4 Old Crowns from the DLC (grants hollowing immunity helmet)
  • Target Ending 3 (Aldia) as the most involved ending to set up

NG+ (Journey 2)

  • Collect +1 ring variants that appear exclusively in NG+
  • Burn Sublime Bone Dust to restore Estus potency
  • Attempt a different ending if you didn't in NG
  • Explore Scholar of the First Sin's remixed enemy placements
  • Start Company of Champions if you want the Vanquisher's Seal challenge
  • Unpetrify Straid and Ornifex again with carried-over Branches

NG+2 (Journey 3)

  • Collect +2 ring variants (e.g., Chloranthy Ring +2, Ring of Blades +2)
  • Push Soul Memory into the highest PvP bracket for competitive play
  • Min-max your build with fully upgraded lategame weapons
  • Farm rare boss weapons by burning Bonfire Ascetics

NG+3 and Beyond

  • Maximize Bonfire Intensity for the hardest version of bosses
  • Challenge runs: SL1, no-shield, specific weapon limitations
  • Grind final covenant ranks (Company of Champions' 50 Awestones)
  • Collect anything missed in previous cycles

Petrified NPCs and Fragrant Branch of Yore — NG+ Planning

Fragrant Branches of Yore are consumed on use and do not regenerate. In NG+, previously unpetrified NPCs and items are re-petrified. Plan your Branch usage across cycles:

Priority NPC / Item Branch Required Location
Critical Straid of Olaphis 1 Branch Lost Bastille
Critical Weaponsmith Ornifex 1 Branch Shaded Ruins
Important Rosabeth of Melfia 1 Branch Majula (access to Shaded Woods)
Optional Royal Sorcerer Navlaan 1 Branch Aldia's Keep (unlocks questline)
Optional Petrified item pickups 1 Branch each Various

Merchant Hag Melentia sells Fragrant Branches for 12,000 Souls each. You can purchase unlimited copies. In NG+, stock up before transitioning.


Recommended Ending Order for Completionists

Cycle Ending Notes
NG Aldia (Third Ending) Most complex — set it up while mechanics are fresh
NG+ Link the Curse Default ending — quick and clean
NG+2 Leave the Throne Walk away for the refusal ending

All three endings can be obtained across three cycles. The Aldia ending is the hardest to set up (requires three specific NPC encounters during the playthrough) and should be prioritized in NG to avoid mismanaging it.