NPC Questline: Benhart of Jugo

Length: Long (spans Majula, Shaded Woods, Shrine of Amana, Dragon Shrine, and Memory of Orro) Rewards: Benhart's Bluemoon Greatsword (a deliberate nod to Dark Souls 1's Moonlight Greatsword), gesture "Eleum Loyce" (clap), and his full armor set Missable: Yes — similar to Lucatiel, you must summon Benhart for at least 3 boss fights and he must survive each one; if he dies in a summoned fight, that fight does not count toward the required three


Overview

Benhart of Jugo is the most immediately likable NPC in Dark Souls II. He is cheerful, brash, and completely in over his head — a knight from a distant land who followed a rumor about a legendary greatsword to the cursed kingdom of Drangleic. He swings his Bluemoon Greatsword with enormous enthusiasm, regardless of whether it actually connects with anything. He is not very good at fighting. He is very good at showing up.

His questline parallels Lucatiel's structurally — meet him in multiple locations, summon him for boss fights, keep him alive — but where Lucatiel's arc is about loss and forgetting, Benhart's is about persistence and misplaced optimism. He never quite understands how outmatched he is. He keeps going anyway.

The Bluemoon Greatsword he carries is a deliberate reference to the Moonlight Greatsword from Dark Souls 1. He believes it is the real thing. It is not. The game is honest about this in the item description. Benhart is not.

Critical Warning: Like Lucatiel, Benhart's questline tracks how many boss fights you complete without summoning him in areas where his sign is available. Summon him and ensure he survives for at least 3 of the available boss fights to complete the questline.


Step-by-Step Walkthrough

Step 1 — First Meeting: Majula

Location: Majula — the cliff area near the monument at the far end of the hub town, overlooking the sea.

Shortly after arriving in Majula, explore to the far cliff edge near the stone monument. Benhart is sitting here, staring at the horizon, sword planted in the ground beside him. He is immediately friendly — almost aggressively so. He introduces himself with a sort of cheerful pride and tells you about his blade, which he calls the Bluemoon Greatsword.

Exhaust all of his dialogue here. He does not mention where he is going next, but he seems energized by the meeting. This first encounter sets the questline flag and is required before he will appear in later locations.

Note: The monument Benhart sits near is the Majula monument, which displays messages from previous players. It is an appropriate spot for a man whose journey is partly shaped by the record of those who came before.


Step 2 — Second Meeting: Shaded Woods (Ruined Fork Road bonfire)

Location: Shaded Woods — the Ruined Fork Road bonfire area, at the three-way split path leading to different ruins.

After entering the Shaded Woods (which requires unpetrifying Rosabeth of Melfia in Majula using a Fragrant Branch of Yore), follow the path until you reach the Ruined Fork Road bonfire. The three-way fork leads to the Shaded Ruins, the foggy forest, and deeper into the Woods.

Benhart is standing near this bonfire. He seems slightly more worn than in Majula but no less enthusiastic. He talks again about his sword and his journey. Exhaust his dialogue completely. His summon sign appears for boss fights in this region — specifically Scorpioness Najka in the Shaded Ruins area.

Action Required: After exhausting dialogue, find his summon sign for the Scorpioness Najka boss fight. Summon him. Keep him alive.

Note on keeping Benhart alive against Najka: Scorpioness Najka is a hybrid scorpion-woman with long-range burrowing attacks and a sand-spray that covers wide areas. Benhart will charge at her recklessly — keep him engaged on one of Najka's side pincers and focus the main body yourself. Healing potions or the Warmth pyromancy near his position can extend his survival.


Step 3 — Third Meeting: Shrine of Amana

Location: Shrine of Amana — near the Crumbled Ruins bonfire, in a side area off the main flooded path.

The Shrine of Amana is a flooded underground temple filled with chanting Amana Priestesses who fire homing soul spears from across the water. It is one of the most disliked areas in DS2 for the constant ranged harassment.

After reaching the Crumbled Ruins bonfire, look for a side passage off the main flooded route. Benhart is standing here, a little damp, still cheerful. His dialogue in this encounter is subtly more tired than before, but he doesn't acknowledge it. Exhaust everything he says.

His summon sign appears for the Demon of Song boss fight in this area.

Action Required: Find his summon sign for the Demon of Song boss fight. Summon him. Keep him alive.

Note on keeping Benhart alive against the Demon of Song: The Demon of Song is a large frog-faced creature whose main attack pattern involves closing distance quickly and swiping. The main danger for Benhart in this fight is the sweeping arm attack that covers a wide horizontal arc. Position yourself as the primary target and bait the demon's attention toward you while Benhart attacks from behind.


Step 4 — Fourth Meeting: Dragon Shrine

Location: Dragon Shrine — on the stairs leading up the shrine exterior, partway through the area.

The Dragon Shrine is a late-game area leading to the Ancient Dragon. On the long exterior staircase ascending the shrine, Benhart is standing partway up, looking out across the view. He is clearly tired now. His dialogue touches on how far he has come, how much he has seen. He still speaks of his sword with pride.

Exhaust all dialogue. His summon sign appears for the Ancient Dragon encounter (if triggered) or for the nearby boss fight depending on your progression.


Step 5 — Final Meeting: Memory of Orro

Location: Memory of Orro — accessed via the large petrified tree in the Forest of Fallen Giants using the Ashen Mist Heart (obtained from the Ancient Dragon in Dragon Shrine).

The Memories of the Giants are dream-like echoes of the past accessed through petrified Giant corpses using the Ashen Mist Heart. Memory of Orro is one of the required memories for the Giant Lord boss fight sequence.

Benhart appears inside Memory of Orro. His summon sign is available for the Giant Lord boss fight — one of the most important mandatory boss fights in the late game, and the final opportunity to summon Benhart.

Action Required: Summon Benhart for the Giant Lord fight. Keep him alive.

If you have summoned him for at least 3 boss fights across the questline and he has survived all of them, after completing the Memory of Orro sequence, Benhart will be available for a final conversation. He will give you his equipment and his gesture before departing.

Reward: Benhart's Bluemoon Greatsword, Benhart's Set (full armor — Jugo armor, Jugo manchettes, Jugo leggings, Benhart's Hat), gesture (a clap)


Boss Fight Summary (Summon Opportunities)

Boss Location Notes
Scorpioness Najka Shaded Woods / Shaded Ruins Available after Ruined Fork Road meeting
Demon of Song Shrine of Amana Available after Shrine of Amana meeting
Giant Lord Memory of Orro Final available summon
Various others Dragon Shrine area Depending on route and flags

You need at least 3 successful survivals from available summons.


Rewards Summary

Reward Condition
Bluemoon Greatsword Final meeting after 3 successful summons
Benhart's Hat Final meeting after 3 successful summons
Jugo armor, manchettes, leggings Final meeting after 3 successful summons
Gesture (clap) Final meeting after 3 successful summons

The Bluemoon Greatsword

Benhart's Bluemoon Greatsword scales primarily with Intelligence and has innate Magic damage — it functions as a magic-infused greatsword for INT-hybrid builds. Its moveset is identical to a standard greatsword with wide horizontal swings and a powerful two-handed stance.

The weapon's item description explicitly states it is a fake — a replica of the legendary Moonlight Greatsword from DS1 that Benhart mistakenly believes is the real thing. Benhart's entire journey to Drangleic was built on this misidentification. The game does not play this for cruelty. It is simply what happened. He fought just as hard with a copy as he would have with the real thing. Perhaps more.

The actual Moonlight Greatsword exists in DS2 as a separate weapon, obtained from the Ancient Dragon soul transpositon.


Lore Notes

Benhart is from Jugo — a distant land barely mentioned anywhere else in the Souls universe. He is not a hero. He is a knight who heard a story about a legendary sword and followed it to the end of the world, and was wrong about almost everything, and kept going anyway.

His questline is not about tragedy or corruption. It is about a person who is genuinely, cheerfully incorrect and somehow makes it to the end of the story regardless. Dark Souls II is full of characters who crumble under the weight of the curse. Benhart does not notice the weight. He is too busy swinging his (probably fake) Moonlight Greatsword at something.

The fact that his reward to you is the sword — not a copy of it, but his specific sword, the one he carried across the world on a mistaken belief — is the questline's final note. He gives you the thing that was wrong, and he gives it with the same warmth he had at the beginning.