NPC Questline: Mild-Mannered Pate & Creighton the Wanderer
Length: Medium (3 Pate encounters, 2 Creighton encounters, one culminating duel) Rewards: Pate's Equipment Set (full armor + spear + shield + ring) OR Creighton's Equipment (Mirrah Greatsword + Mirrah Set), depending on who you side with Missable: Yes — Pate's encounters in Earthen Peak and Brightstone Cove Tseldora are easy to miss if you advance the areas without exhausting his dialogue; the White Soapstone exchange is required to trigger the final duel
Overview
Mild-Mannered Pate and Creighton the Wanderer are two of Dark Souls II's most cleverly constructed NPCs. They are mirror images of suspicion: when you first meet each one, they immediately warn you about the other. Pate says Creighton is a dangerous murderer. Creighton says Pate is a treacherous schemer who lures travelers into traps. Both sound entirely plausible. Both are correct.
This questline is built around a classic Dark Souls tradition: letting the player observe without fully explaining, and rewarding attention. The "trapped chest" at the start of Forest of Fallen Giants is Pate's calling card. Creighton's shackled hands are his. Neither is innocent. The only question is which one you help survive.
Note: The questline ends in a duel between the two NPCs — you do not fight either of them yourself in the final step, though Creighton can invade you earlier as a hostile. You simply facilitate the confrontation and loot the winner.
Step-by-Step Walkthrough
Step 1 — Meet Pate: Forest of Fallen Giants
Location: Forest of Fallen Giants — the room with the suspicious iron chest, reached through a narrow archway above the central courtyard.
Shortly into the Forest of Fallen Giants, you will come to a room that Pate is standing outside of, warning you. He describes himself as a traveler, helpful and cautious, and he warns you not to enter the room ahead — there's a trap. He is telling the truth about the trap. He is lying about everything else.
If you ignore his warning and enter the room, you will trigger a gate trap (portcullis drops behind you) and get swarmed. If you escape, Pate is waiting outside looking concerned. Exhaust all of his dialogue either way. He gives you his White Sign Soapstone (a unique item that will be needed later) and speaks warmly of cooperation.
Exhaust every line of dialogue with Pate here. Do not rush past him.
Reward: Pate's White Sign Soapstone
Note on the trapped chest: The iron chest in the room Pate warns you about does contain loot. If you triggered the gate trap and survived, you can open the chest safely. Pate set the trap — but you can still get the items.
Step 2 — Meet Creighton: Huntsman's Copse
Location: Huntsman's Copse — a locked cell in the cave passage before the Undead Lockaway bonfire, reached early in the area.
In Huntsman's Copse, as you navigate the cave passage toward the first bonfire, you will hear a voice from inside a locked cell. Creighton the Wanderer is locked inside, shackled, and furious. He demands you release him.
To open his cell, you need the Forgotten Key — a key found by defeating the two Ogres in the pit area accessible from Majula's large pit (The Pit). The Forgotten Key is on a corpse in the dark cave beneath the pit.
To get the Forgotten Key:
- From Majula, find the large pit (The Pit) and descend via a ladder or careful fall-management.
- Navigate the cave at the bottom, dealing with Ogres.
- Retrieve the Forgotten Key from the corpse in the cave.
- Return to Huntsman's Copse and use the key on Creighton's cell.
When you free him, Creighton immediately warns you about Pate — describes him as a silver-tongued schemer who traps travelers. He is telling the truth about Pate. He is also a convicted murderer. Both things are true.
Exhaust all of Creighton's dialogue after freeing him. He will relocate.
Note: Creighton can also invade you as a red phantom in Huntsman's Copse if you are in human form (holding a Human Effigy's restored status). His invasion is separate from the main questline progression and is not required to complete the quest.
Step 3 — Second Pate Encounter: Earthen Peak
Location: Earthen Peak — a room past the Central Earthen Peak bonfire, near the upper windmill area.
As you ascend through Earthen Peak, Pate appears in a room off the main path past the Central Earthen Peak bonfire. He seems pleased to see you — not suspiciously pleased, just cheerfully opportunistic. He comments on the dangers of the area and offers vague encouragement.
Exhaust his dialogue completely. His presence here is not trap-related — it is simply to maintain the questline thread and advance his conversation history with you. Missing this encounter does not necessarily break the questline, but exhausting his dialogue at each location ensures all flags are properly set.
Step 4 — Third Pate Encounter: Brightstone Cove Tseldora
Location: Brightstone Cove Tseldora — near the Chapel Threshold bonfire, in the area with the large spider webs and the ruined chapel.
Pate appears again in Brightstone Cove Tseldora, near the Chapel Threshold bonfire. The area is overrun with spider enemies and the ruins of a scholar's town. Pate is waiting, again appearing helpful and slightly smug.
Exhaust his dialogue completely here. This is the final Pate encounter before the questline resolution. He will give you something to hold — or acknowledge the soapstone exchange — setting up the final confrontation.
Step 5 — Give Pate's White Soapstone to Creighton
Location: Find Creighton after his Huntsman's Copse encounter — he relocates near Brightstone Cove Tseldora or can be found in the area around the same time as Pate's third appearance.
After meeting both NPCs across their respective encounter chains, show Creighton the Pate's White Sign Soapstone that Pate gave you at the start. Creighton will recognize it immediately. His reaction makes it clear he knows what it means — and that he intends to act on that information.
This exchange is the trigger for the final confrontation.
Note: The White Sign Soapstone itself is a functional item — you can use it to leave cooperative summon signs for other players. The questline does not consume or destroy it. Showing it to Creighton is a dialogue flag, not an item transfer.
Step 6 — The Final Duel
Location: A room in Brightstone Cove Tseldora near the Chapel Threshold bonfire — the same area where Pate had his third encounter.
After the soapstone exchange with Creighton, return to the room where Pate last appeared. You will find both NPCs engaged in or having just completed a confrontation. One of them is dead. The other is wounded.
If Pate wins: You find Pate standing over Creighton's corpse. You can loot Creighton's equipment (Mirrah Greatsword, Mirrah Set) from Creighton's body. Pate thanks you insincerely and goes on his way. You can kill Pate afterward to loot his own equipment set, or simply leave him.
If Creighton wins: You find Creighton standing over Pate's corpse. You can loot Pate's equipment (Pate's Spear, Pate's Shield, Pate's Set, Pate's Ring) from Pate's body.
Reward (Creighton wins): Pate's Spear, Pate's Shield, Pate's Set (full armor), Pate's Ring (+stamina recovery rate) Reward (Pate wins): Creighton's Mirrah Greatsword, Mirrah Set (full armor)
To guarantee getting both sets: Kill whichever NPC survives the duel immediately after it ends. Both sets are obtainable in a single playthrough by looting the loser and killing the winner.
Rewards Summary
| Reward | Source |
|---|---|
| Pate's White Sign Soapstone | Pate's first encounter in Forest of Fallen Giants |
| Pate's Spear | Loot from Pate's corpse (if Creighton wins or you kill Pate) |
| Pate's Shield | Loot from Pate's corpse |
| Pate's Set (full armor) | Loot from Pate's corpse |
| Pate's Ring | Loot from Pate's corpse |
| Creighton's Mirrah Greatsword | Loot from Creighton's corpse (if Pate wins or you kill Creighton) |
| Mirrah Set (full armor) | Loot from Creighton's corpse |
Pate's Ring
Pate's Ring increases stamina regeneration rate — a universally useful stat for any build that relies on heavy attacks, blocking, or sustained combat. It is one of the better utility rings in DS2 for quality and strength builds that burn through stamina quickly.
Lore Notes
The Pate and Creighton questline is Dark Souls II's most morally ambiguous NPC arc, and deliberately so. Pate is a schemer who lures travelers into traps and robs the survivors. Creighton is a convicted murderer whose shackles suggest his crimes were taken seriously enough to warrant imprisonment. Both warn you about the other. Both are right.
The questline makes no judgment. It places two dangerous men in your path, gives you just enough information to see them clearly, and then lets you watch them destroy each other. The player's role is facilitator and observer.
Pate's "mild-mannered" descriptor in his name is the game winking at you. He is mild-mannered in the same way a trap is quiet before it fires.
The trapped chest in the Forest of Fallen Giants is where the game first asks you to notice something is wrong. Most players miss it and get trapped anyway — and then let Pate explain it away. That is the questline in miniature.